About me

Get new posts by email.

About me

Reform of the Mental Health Act

Mental HealthLabour have long wanted to reform the Mental Health Act, and made their first attempt with the Mental Health Bill 2002, which failed rather spectacularly. Several further attempts have also proved fruitless. But now they’re having an all-new attempt at reforming the Act.

Firstly, in true modern NHS style, it now means that the range of people empowered to do things is vastly extended. Where the power to detain people and force treatment upon them was previously restricted to a select few with the necessary skill and experience, the Government now wants to extend this power to a great many more people – in fact, pretty much anyone who claims to work with the Mental Health sector who’s been on a short course. And it will be the Social Service – not medics – who decide if someone can be deemed to be an Approved Mental Health Professional.

This is nurse-prescribing gone mad. Of course, Mental Health nurses have long been highly trained in the detention of individuals for short periods, and they play a very important role in this arena. But now the government wants to open this up to any Mental Health professional. Dodgy counsellors will no medical training will soon be able to sign up for a course, then will be able to detain people. That sounds unhelpful.

Just to make it even easier for these poorly trained individuals to know who they can round up, the Government would like to change the definition of a Mental Disorder. Instead of detailed definitions of each kind of disorder, the Government now wants us to accept “any disorder or disability of the mind” as a definition. This is beyond stupidity. Now, anyone who has epilepsy or has suffered a stroke or has any number of conditions suddenly falls under the provisions of the Mental Health Act, and the mountains of bureaucracy that entails. I’m sure that’ll come as a particular delight to overworked GPs, general physicians, and mental health workers nationwide.

And, ho-hum, they feel a need to better regulate these powers. So they’re introducing much greater use of Mental Health Tribunals. Anyone who’s ever tried to organise a Tribunal for a patient will know that it’s damn-near impossible, so to use more of them seems – well, not a great idea.

Yet this stinking piece of terrible legislation is getting very little media coverage because of public embarrassment about Mental Health.

There is one glimmer of hope – It’s hard to deny that most of the Cabinet have “disorders of the mind”, so we can wait till they pass the new legislation, then lock the lot of ’em up. If Yates of the Yard doesn’t get there first…

This post was filed under: Health, News and Comment, Politics.

Recently published posts

‘Fallen leaves’ / 17 April 2024

A manifestly different outcome / 16 April 2024

Forgotten promises / 15 April 2024

Souter Lighthouse / 14 April 2024

Mul’s at the pub / 13 April 2024

The hazards of changing a battery / 12 April 2024

Random posts from the archive

Photo-a-day 296: @NHSFluFighter / 23 October 2012

Email constipation / 01 March 2006

Birthday Happiness / 25 June 2004

Human failings / 11 November 2023

From above / 15 February 2019

Photo-a-day 335: Christmas tree / 01 December 2012

Comments and responses

Comment from impatientpatient

    23.30, 18/03/2007

Just a thought-

Why on earth is ANYONE even looking to the medical/biological causes and cures of mental illness, if doctors will not be allowed to doctor those who are mentally ill? A rhetorical question, I guess…..

I live in Canada, and our provincial government has amended our mental health act to basically be able to detain people against their will, as a response to a policeman being killed a few years ago by a man who was clearly mentally unstable. This worries me because we are emulating your system in a lot of ways, and our previous health minister waxed eloquently about how wonderful the NHS was, with its mix of private and public. The difference is, they are cost cutting by allowing pharmacists to dispense and change meds, using nurse practitioners more, and all that, but no-one is talking about it except in glowing terms. We have a dearth of doctors and so they are being replaced by everyone else, at the expense of those who need doctors.


Nice article anyways. Came thru NHS Blog Doc.

Compose a new comment

I'm not taking comments on my blog any more, so I'm afraid the opportunity to add to this discussion has passed.

The content of this site is copyright protected by a Creative Commons License, with some rights reserved. All trademarks, images and logos remain the property of their respective owners. The accuracy of information on this site is in no way guaranteed. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author. No responsibility can be accepted for any loss or damage caused by reliance on the information provided by this site. Information about cookies and the handling of emails submitted for the 'new posts by email' service can be found in the privacy policy. This site uses affiliate links: if you buy something via a link on this site, I might get a small percentage in commission. Here's hoping.