» sjhoward.co.uk

  • « Archive »
  • « Academia »
  • « Book »
  • « About Me »
  • « Twitter »
  • « RSS »
  • Dan Brown: Digital Fortress


    Nobody can claim that I haven’t given Dan Brown a fair crack at entertaining me. I’ve read The Da Vinci Coda, Angels and Demons, as well as Digital Fortress. And, at least as far as I can see, the best complement I can give the books is the one I first gave them: ‘irritatingly gripping tosh’.

    Just like the other two, Digital Fortress is by no means deep, considered, or erudite. It’s a quick story, completely lacking depth, and riddled with predictability. The most irritating part of Digital Fortress was the final thirty pages, where the solution to the whole problem of the book was glaringly obvious, and yet apparently the most accomplished cryptographers in the world were unable to work it out. And, despite having earlier demonstrated an intimiate knowledge of other obscure chemicals like freon, they are unable to recall basic facts about the most famous of all elements. And for a miliatary organisation, there’s an awful lot of insubordination.

    And why on earth would one build a dome to house a top secret computer that had both a see-through glass roof to allow any passing spy satellites to have a close look, and given that this computer could melt-down at any time, have no effective emergency exits? And why would a department housing the most accomplished cryptographers have physical security barriers protected with passwords rather than keys? It’s all a little bit bizarre. There are so many gaping plot holes, I often wondered if I was about to plunge into one never to be seen again.

    Brown has clearly tried to throw in a little bit of interpersonal relationships into this novel, trying to give us confused signals about who loves who, and what’s going on in various romances. Instead, the whole thing ends up looking freakishly incestuous. And yet that angle is completely ignored.

    The problem with the novel is that it is genuinely gripping, because you want to carry on reading to find out where the characters are finally going to catch up with the obvious. Have they not realised that every passing observation they make later plays a key role in a Dan Brown novel?

    There’s really very little to recommend about Dan Brown. Unless you happen to be fans of both cryptography and the Catholic Church. Because even in a novel about NSA cryptography, there still has to be a moment of high drama in a Catholic Church. It feels like Brown is desperately trying to avoid dragging the church into it, but can’t quite resist. The only other thing to recommend is that it is extremely easy reading. You don’t need to engage your brain, there’s no complicated moral or philosophical puzzles posed, no deep meanings; you just let the words wash over your eyes. And try to resist the urge to scream out in frustration.

    As I hope you’ll have gathered by now, this isn’t a book I’d particularly recommend. It’s not even an author I’d particularly recommend. But if you do feel the urge to read it, you can buy it ‘cheap as chips’ using the links on the right.






    Comment

    Share


    Your Comments and Responses

    Comment from Person

    I thought the book was complete rubbish.

    27th July 2005 | Permalink

    » This comment was received at 04:19 on 27 July 05


    Comment from Anonymous

    you are absolutely right. To be kind, I´m sure Mr.Brown has never been to Seville, someone must have wanted to cheat him..

    23rd August 2005 | Permalink

    » This comment was received at 19:44 on 23 August 05


    Comment from Anonymous

    You are absolutely right. To be kind with Mr.Brown, I´m sure he has never been to Seville, someone must have tried to cheat him..

    23rd August 2005 | Permalink

    » This comment was received at 19:46 on 23 August 05


    Comment from Anonymous

    I am a sevillian girl and I feel very desappointed with this “writer”. I really thought that Dan Brown was a man who investigate seriously in order to make his novels, but now I know his a botcher and mediocre writer…

    26th August 2005 | Permalink

    » This comment was received at 15:32 on 26 August 05


    Comment from the original poster, sjhoward

    As much as I agree with all the commenters above, you do have to respect the fact that Mr Brown’s work has sold tens of thousands of copies, and made him a very rich man – which, at the end of the day, was probably his foremost aim.

    Go given the success of his novels(however bad they were), can he really be that bad a writer? Or was it all down to marketing?

    26th August 2005 | Permalink

    » This comment was received at 17:48 on 26 August 05


    Elsewhere on the site

    This post has been referenced by another on this site:
    sjhoward.co.uk » Summer Books: Digital Fortress by Dan Brown

    [...] review was originally posted here on sjhoward.co.uk in April 2005, and has been re-versioned for the ‘Summer Books’ series of [...]

    18th February 2012 | Permalink

    » This pingback was received at 00:00 on 18 February 12


    Write a new comment or response

    Commenting allows you to respond to what the author and other commenters have been said. Comments often appear on this page instantly, though sometimes take a little longer - especially if you are new to the site.

    Enter your comment in the text area below. You may use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> .

    Note: By submitting your comment, you confirm that it conforms to the site's Comment Policy.
    Gravatar: To show your face, sign up for Gravatar, and enter your email address above.





    Welcome to my blog!
    I've been writing here since May 2003, and waffle on about all sorts of stuff.
    See this page for more about me, or follow me on twitter. Enjoy browsing, commenting, and getting involved!


    Printed from http://sjhoward.co.uk/archive/2005/04/19/dan-brown-digital-fortress
    (c) sjhoward.co.uk - full conditions can be viewed at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/2.0/uk/
    The content of this site is copyright protected by a Creative Commons License, with some rights reserved. All trademarks, images and logos remain the property of their respective owners. The accuracy of information on this site is in no way guaranteed. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author. No responsibility can be accepted for any loss or damage caused by reliance on the information provided by this site.