About me
About me

2D: The Pope’s resignation

I’ve read two very interesting articles on the Pope’s resignation recently. The first, by Stephen Crittenden of The Global Mail, casts the resignation as an act that almost heralds the end of Catholicism. He gives a strong argument to suggest that the Vatican is in total crisis. It’s certainly a dramatic take on the situation, and is well worth a read.

From a totally different perspective, Xuyang Jingjing writes in the (similarly named but very different) Global Times about the particular challenges the Pope’s resignation poses for Chinese Catholics. The fact that I was previously unaware of the difficult relationship between China and the Vatican probably reveals more about my own ignorance than anything else, but it made the article far more intriguing for me.

2D posts appear on alternate Wednesdays. For 2D, I pick two interesting articles that look at an issue from two different – though not necessarily opposing – perspectives. I hope you enjoy them!

This 1,998th post was filed under: 2D.

Some recently published posts

What I’ve been reading this month / May 2020, 10 minutes long

What I’ve been reading this month / April 2020, 13 minutes long

A €38m lesson with my latte / March 2020, 11 minutes long

What I’ve been reading this month / March 2020, 14 minutes long

Interesting… isch. / February 2020, 3 minutes long

Some random old posts

Vote Blair! / February 2005, Less than a minute long

Desktop app of the week: Reeder / May 2012, 1 minute long

Dissertation reject / September 2011, Less than a minute long

A Post / June 2003, Less than a minute long

The private sector will always be involved in the NHS / January 2015, 11 minutes long

Archbishop complains. Nobody suprised. / June 2005, Less than a minute long

Comments and responses

Comment from Julie

by Julie

Comment posted at 00:34 on 14th March 2013.

Here’s a third interesting article you should read and I think Cornwell may be right on this;


I think Benedict has been planning this for a while. Back in 2009 he visited the tome of Celestine, the last pope to resign and left his palium there. He is in effect sacking the Curia and clearing the way for the new man.

Comment from sjhoward (author of the post)

by sjhoward

Comment posted at 08:44 on 15th March 2013.

Thanks for that, Julie.

John Cornwell has, of course, written extensively about several popes, and is very well respected in his field. Cornwell might be right here; however, the accusations – both implied and stated – in his article are serious, and he fails to give any clearly stated firm foundation for them. As a result, that article reads to me like a vitriolic attack on a number of people based on little more than gossip and speculation.

On top of that, I am utterly disgusted by his bizarre use of language: He refers to people he accuses of acts which can only be described as some of the most harrowing forms of child abuse as having, merely, “a weakness”. And the way in which he appears to conflate homosexuality and paedophilia turns my stomach.

As is well documented, I’m no fan of the Catholic church, in whose name (and under whose protection) despicable crimes have been committed time and again. But making the extraordinary claims seen in this article on the basis of gossip and speculation alone is simply not on, however unpleasant the accused.

Comment from Julie

by Julie

Comment posted at 20:03 on 15th March 2013.

Hi SJ,

Just to be clear, I’m a Catholic and I’m no fan of Cornwell. I don’t agree with everything that he’s written in this article, but I think he’s correct that the Pope has resigned to clear out the Curia in one go. There has been something akin to a civil war going on in the Vatican over the past decade and Benedict himself ran into it, when he tried to have a particularly nasty abuser called Maciel sacked. He was headed off at the pass by Sodano, the then Vatican Secretary of State and Maciel stayed in place. When Benedict became Pope, he replaced Sodano, sacked Maciel and made a number of other reforms, but I think that whatever is in the locked safe at the Vatican has dictated that he sweep the lot away. Anyway, the next few months and years will tell, I suppose.

Compose a new comment


You may use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong> .

If you would like to display a profile picture beside your comment, sign up for Gravatar, and enter your email address above.

By submitting your comment, you confirm that it conforms to the site's comment policy. Comments are subject to both automatic and human moderation, and may take some time to appear.

The content of this site is copyright protected by a Creative Commons License, with some rights reserved. All trademarks, images and logos remain the property of their respective owners. The accuracy of information on this site is in no way guaranteed. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author. No responsibility can be accepted for any loss or damage caused by reliance on the information provided by this site. This site uses cookies - click here for more information.