About me
Bookshop

Get new posts by email.

About me

For the good of Labour, Brown should battle on

Several MPs, ministers, and political commentators appear to want Gordon Brown to resign as leader of the Labour Party. God knows why: These lefties seem to think that sacking Brown would be good for Labour when, in reality, it would be anything but.

Labour cannot win the next election. Barring the hugely unexpected, Labour is now by far the most damaged political party, and the Conservatives are well into an inexorable resurgence. The political wind in the country, stirred up by Big Bad Blair, is now circling Downing Street and will huff, puff, and blow down Labour’s house with surety.

Labour’s popularity is in its boots as it is, and whilst Mr Brown is hardly boosting it, it is most certainly the party which is damaged now, not the leadership, and it cannot win the next election until it has undergone a Cameronesque detoxification. And,as Carol Voderman will tell you, you can’t detoxify when under the pressure of Government.

As if that weren’t enough, governments undoubtedly live and die through economic cycles. Few governments could hope to survive the present economic downturn, and both Labour and Brown – who have previously sung so enthusiastically about how they control the economy – have dug their own graves. Taking credit for the upward economic stroke has now left their popularity careering head-first down the slippery slope of economic downturn.

Of course, Brown’s fervent support for the merger of HBOS and Lloyds TSB this week is a further mistake: He’s backing a process which he doesn’t entirely control, and any regulatory hurdles the process stumbles at will be painted as Brown losing his influence. There’s a reason why back-room deals and discussions should stay in the back room.

But still, he shouldn’t resign. Labour failing under Brown is infinitely better for the Party than Labour failing under two leaders. Labour can’t win the next general election, but with a new leader, a lick of paint, and some enthusiastic party unity, they can purge themselves back into power reasonably quickly – and that’s where minds should be focussed.

To elect another leader now and yet still lose the next election will damage the Party far more: Failure under one leader can be painted as the failure of a bad apple, fail under two consecutive leaders and the country thinks whole orchard is rotten. Allegiance is switched to pears.

Of course, such is the nature of politics, few Labour MPs genuinely care about the long-term future of the party. The career politicians in marginal seats would desperately like to keep their jobs at the next election, and see Brown as damaging the Party. They want to chuck him out to give themselves a flicker of hope of avoiding their P45 for another Parliamentary term. Frankly, they’d stand a better chance if they crossed the floor.

This Labour government is undoubtedly moribund. There are no heroes in the wings waiting to swoop in a resuscitate their chances. The only sensible thing to hope for now is a dignified death, in the hope that the rebirth can be swift.

Brown simply must not go.

This post was filed under: News and Comment, Politics, , , , .

Recently published posts

Weeknotes 2022.25 / 26 June 2022

Weeknotes 2022.24 / 19 June 2022

Weeknotes 2022.23 / 12 June 2022

Weeknotes 2022.22 / 05 June 2022

31 things I learned in May 2021 / 31 May 2022

Weeknotes 2022.21 / 29 May 2022




Random posts from the archive

Quote Unquote / 03 May 2005

Photo-a-day 269: Postcard from @readmatter / 25 September 2012

Philosophy and Su Doku / 11 May 2005

Email constipation / 01 March 2006

The end for Blair? / 06 May 2006

Photo-a-day 262: Library / 18 September 2012




Comments and responses

Comment from Helen Wright


    20.54, 18/09/2008

And for the good of England – McLabour and the British must go


Comment from Anonymous


    12.31, 20/10/2008

NEW LABOUR STINKS GORDON BROWN IS THE DAVID BRENT RICKY GERVAIS LEADER HE IS HATED BY ALL FOOLISH PEOPLE WHO PUT LABOUR IN 1997 HISTORY SHOWS THAT WHEN LABOUR GET IN POWER THEY PARTY LIKE ITS 1999 TO QUOTE THE SONG BY PRINCE THEY SHIT ON THE POOR ORDINARY MAN THEN MAKE CONSERVATIVES LOOK BAD BY SPENDING LIKE MAD THUS FORCING THE CLEANERS AKA TORIES TO COPE WITH A BARE CUPBOARD GIVING THEM NO CHOICE TO TAX US FURTHER AFTER NEW AND OLD LABOURS POLICY OF TAXING US EVERY WAY THEY CAN BUT LOOSE 2 QUOTE CLINT EASTWOOD FILM WITH THE MONKEY. PUT THAT ON DAILY POLITICS SHOW BBC2 AS FOR FLASH GORDON BROWN THE VOTERS WILL BE MING THE MERCILESS IN NEXT GENERAL ELECTION GORDON BROWN TO GET VOTED OUT AND THE COUNTY WILL CELEBRATE CHAMPAGNE STYLE




Compose a new comment

I'm not taking comments on my blog any more, so I'm afraid the opportunity to add to this discussion has passed.




The content of this site is copyright protected by a Creative Commons License, with some rights reserved. All trademarks, images and logos remain the property of their respective owners. The accuracy of information on this site is in no way guaranteed. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author. No responsibility can be accepted for any loss or damage caused by reliance on the information provided by this site. Information about cookies and the handling of emails submitted for the 'new posts by email' service can be found in the privacy policy. This site uses affiliate links: if you buy something via a link on this site, I might get a small percentage in commission. Here's hoping.